15 August 2025 | BEAD News
Heavy fiber Buildouts Despite Satellite Eligibility
Virginia Finalizes $613 Million BEAD Funding Proposal
Virginia has quietly released its “Benefit of the Bargain” award recommendations for the Broadband Equity, Access, and Deployment (BEAD) program, outlining how $613 million will be distributed. The allocations, which still need approval from the National Telecommunications and Information Administration (NTIA), are shaped by the revised BEAD rules announced in June. Those updates removed the earlier “fiber-first” requirement and opened the process to “technology-neutral” bids from fiber, satellite, cable, and fixed wireless providers.
Even with this broadened eligibility, the state’s plan heavily favors fiber projects. SpaceX’s Starlink and Amazon’s Project Kuiper each secured a portion of the funding, but the majority of awards are going to fiber buildouts.
From Fiber Priority to Technology Neutrality
The BEAD rule changes—introduced earlier this year by the Trump administration—gave satellite providers equal footing with fiber operators in the competition for funds. The U.S. Commerce Department framed the shift as a way to support faster and more cost-efficient deployment in hard-to-reach areas. The adjustments opened more opportunities for companies like Starlink and Kuiper to compete nationwide.
Fiber Still Claims the Largest Share
Despite these changes, Virginia’s award breakdown still overwhelmingly favors fiber connections. New Street Research estimates that 81% of locations will be served by fiber, 10% by satellite, 8% by cable, and 1% by fixed wireless.
Virginia and Louisiana stand out as the only two states so far recommending that most BEAD funds be directed toward fiber under the revised rules. State leaders say the decision is rooted in fiber’s superior capacity, durability, and ability to meet long-term demand.
Satellite Funding Remains Limited
Under Virginia’s plan, Starlink will receive just under $3.3 million to connect 5,579 locations—about $584 per site—while Project Kuiper will get $4.4 million for roughly 7,000 sites at $641 each. Combined, these satellite projects represent just $7.7 million, or about 1.3% of the total funding.
The largest fiber award went to All Points Broadband, which secured more than $171 million to serve nearly 20,000 sites at an average cost of $8,655 per location. Some of these builds are expected to deliver speeds up to 10 gigabits per second.
Performance, Reliability, and Environmental Factors
Drew Garner of the Benton Institute for Broadband and Society said Virginia’s evaluation process considered not only cost, but also speed, latency, scalability, and environmental conditions. Dense tree cover—common in the state—can hinder satellite performance. SpaceX has promoted beam-switching technology to address such issues, though skepticism remains.
Fiber’s symmetrical gigabit speeds and immunity to congestion make it the preferred long-term solution. Satellite networks, on the other hand, can slow down when too many users share the same beam. In high-demand areas of the Pacific Northwest, Starlink has even implemented a $1,000 surcharge to deter new sign-ups in saturated zones.
In Virginia’s $613 million BEAD program, fiber-optic projects claim most funding
No Requirements for Low-Income Plans
Under the updated BEAD rules, satellite providers must ensure download speeds of at least 100 Mbps and upload speeds of 20 Mbps for all funded homes. In Virginia, eligible households will receive a free Starlink dish for the program’s 10-year term.
However, states can no longer require providers to set specific low-income plan prices. Providers must only offer at least one qualifying affordable package, which may be one of their standard offerings. With Starlink’s regular residential plan costing $120 per month, advocates worry that cost—more than access—will remain a barrier.
Debate Over BEAD’s New Direction
Evan Feinman, former BEAD program director who resigned in protest of the policy shift, applauded Virginia’s strategy within the revised framework but criticized the requirement to include satellite. He argued that substituting satellite for fiber could lead to slower speeds and higher monthly bills for some households.
Supporters, including Joe Kane of the Information Technology and Innovation Foundation, point to cost efficiency, while Governor Glenn Youngkin has emphasized a projected $200 million in savings—about 25% less than earlier broadband proposals.
Top Award Recipients and Technology Mix
Twenty-one providers are set to receive BEAD funds in Virginia. Comcast tops the list with 24,343 locations, followed by All Points Broadband with 19,801. Amazon Kuiper and SpaceX will serve 6,957 and 5,579 locations, respectively.
Other large fiber recipients include RiverStreet Networks (13,509), Ztel (12,985), Connect Holding/Brightspeed (4,963), and Verizon (4,645). Smaller allocations went to cable and fixed wireless providers, ensuring a mix of delivery methods.
Full List of Virginia BEAD “Benefit of the Bargain” Awardees
Company | Locations |
---|---|
Comcast | 24,343 |
All Points Broadband | 19,801 |
RiverStreet Networks | 13,509 |
Ztel | 12,985 |
Amazon Kuiper* | 6,957* |
EMPOWER | 6,512 |
SpaceX* | 5,579* |
Connect Holding (Brightspeed) | 4,963 |
Verizon | 4,645 |
Hosted Backbone/Port 80 | 4,573 |
Eastern Shore of Va. Broadband Authority | 4,119 |
GigaBeam Networks | 3,986 |
Point Broadband | 3,757 |
WiFiber | 2,759 |
Global Technical Networks/SPARQ | 2,304 |
IBT Group | 1,519 |
Kinex | 1,278 |
Citizens Telephone | 840 |
FiberLync | 831 |
MGW Communications | 600 |
Scott County Telephone Cooperative | 543 |
Firefly (CVEC) | 486 |
IWISP | 279 |
Cogeco US (Delmar) dba Breezeline | 48 |
Source: Virginia DHCD.
*Satellite providers
◼️
More on Public Broadband
- More of our recent stories about BEAD and public broadband programs
- For up-to-date information on the $42 billion BEAD Program, check Brander Group’s BEAD funding progress dashboard
Other Popular Blog Posts
Discover more from Brander Group
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
Leave a Reply
Want to join the discussion?Feel free to contribute!